Showing posts with label Yasujiro Ozu. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Yasujiro Ozu. Show all posts

6 August 2012

MIFFburger #2: Like Someone in Love


Abbas Kiarostami, 2012  
 
  Fresh out of the Cannes Film Festival, Like Someone in Love is a truly international collaboration. Directed by an Iranian, made with French funding and filmed in Japan(ese). Abbas Kiarostami is a filmmaker I am pretty much completely unfamiliar with. I am also continually getting his name mixed up with Aki Kaurismäki. If we threw in an Akira Kurosawa, Alexander McKendrick or some other A.K. initials my brain would probably start melting out of my ears. Anyway, Kiarostami is quite well known for his dramas, what I do know is that Taste of Cherry won the Palme d’Or in 1997 and he has also made no secret of his Yasujiro Ozu love and influence, even dedicating a film to him. And so it seems that Kiarostami has set himself something of a challenge in journeying to Japan to make his latest feature; a slow moving, dialogue-driven, yet visually beautiful drama.

Rin Takanashi plays the film’s main character Akiko, a young student who works an escort. She has been instructed by her pimp/manager (a small role played by Denden, who was a bit jarring to see so soon after watching Cold Fish) to travel to a client’s house; very little information is given on him apart from him being described as an important man and old friend. But Akiko has her misgivings. In addition to her usual university studies and overbearing fiancé (Ryo Kase), her Grandmother has come to Tokyo for the day to visit her, a small but moving reference to Ozu’s Tokyo Story, that doesn’t feel like a forced inclusion. The film basically follows Akiko’s movements and interactions over a time frame of a little under twenty-four hours. She meets her client, an elderly man (Tadashi Okuno) who seems to want nothing more than some conversation and someone to have dinner with and also has an awkward run in with her fiancé.

The film has very little story line and is very much character driven. Kiarostami’s actors are all very good and serve as the heart of the film, Rin Takashi’s performance ranges from immature and annoying to confident professional, to helpless victim as film’s settings change and characters come and go. Through her wide range feels a bit scattershot at first, she succeeds in aptly conveying her youthful confusion and lack of direction along with her characters weaknesses and strengths. Throughout the film she really does seem to change before our eyes, quite an interesting performance.

What I found most interesting about the film was Kiarostami’s use of camerawork; what is seen, what is unseen, and how this is achieved. As the film opens we hear Akiko, but don’t see her. A completely static shot of a dimly lit restaurant interior captures the goings on as people enter and leave the frame. It soon becomes clear that Akiko is off camera, talking on the phone. Throughout the entire film, Kiarostami obscures or distances his characters, the camera refuses to move to accommodate them (another Ozu-ism). They are hidden in other rooms, sit just out of frame, peer through windows or remain within cars. Reflective surfaces are beautifully used, one of my favourite scenes featured Akiko’s blurry figure, seen only in the reflection of a switched off television screen, charged with a certain eroticism yet disconnection. Also, downtown Shinjuku as seen from a taxi hasn’t looked this good since Lost in Translation. Kiarostami’s artistic touches are not just visual either. Characters are often heard, but not seen. Quiet, distant voices are squeezed through telephones, chatter out of radios or echo from the streets outside. It is such a quiet film, no score is used, the only music heard exists entirely within the world of the film, the jazz standard from which the film takes its name is so subtly included it could easily be missed, and rare instances of raised voices or loud noises elicited startled jumps from the audience.

For me, all these artistic elements are what make this film worth watching. It is very slow moving, with no real climaxes or turning points, and is basically just a few characters talking to each other. While the dialogue ranges from gently comedic, to a short and interesting discourse on art, it is mostly centred around the nature of relationships, and I feel that without these aforementioned stylistic inclusions, the film would probably have been quite a dry drama. In fact, I think many people in the MIFF audience saw it as just that; a few people walked out, and it received a very half hearted applause at the end, which, it should be noted, comes quite suddenly. I won’t give away what happens, but it seems to end just as the film begins to enter into new territory. Relationships are beginning to develop; complications are arising, and then the film ends, changing everything that came before it. However I though this ending as a great conclusion. It serves to snap viewers out of a film that up until now has been perfectly content with drifting along at its own pace, a perfect note for Kiarostami to end his film upon. Many people will find it boring, but I quite enjoyed watching it. I can’t see myself revisiting it any time soon, but if you like a good drama with something a bit extra, or are a Kiarostami fan (again, I really can’t comment on his other work) chances are you’ll find something to enjoy here.

6 July 2012

Still Walking

歩いても 歩いても Hirokazu Koreeda, 2008
 Soon after watching Hirokazu Koreeda’s Nobody Knows, I quickly sought out and watched his 2008 film Still Walking, which, as with much of Koreeda’s work has been likened to Japan’s master drama director Yasujiro Ozu, who I know I keep namedropping and I promise I will get around to having a closer look at one of his films soon, as I’m still quite unschooled in Ozu.

Still Walking establishes one of its primary filmic themes from the very first image: food. The elderly Toshiko and her daughter Chinami are preparing all kinds of Japanese vegetables, for what reason it is not yet known. On the other hand, Kyohei, retired doctor and head of the Yokoyama family sets the films’ title in motion and takes a stroll through his neighbourhood, revealing beautiful scenery and paths that snake through the hills in this surprisingly green neighbourhood that rests somewhere between suburban and country. It is this neighbourhood and the grandparents Toshiko and Kyohei’s home that will be the stage for the film, while the process of food preparation and walking become two important ritual-like activities, particularly when shared.

The Yokoyama house is alive with activity, Chinami, her husband and their two children, constantly running around yelling and playing like kids do, are soon joined by the Yokoyama son Ryota, who has recently married Yukari, a widow with a young son. Ryota is clearly uncomfortable about visiting his parents and introducing his new wife to them, even explaining to his wife that he wants to stay for as little time as possible. Through his trivial complaints and offhand comments such as “If we make it through today we won’t have to see them for a while” a clear sense of family detachment is conveyed. The reason for these small but accumulative tensions slowly become clear through Koreeda’s almost unnoticeable dropping of tiny hints, many of which are visual. It is only until the family and their relationships to one another have been expertly established that Koreeda gently informs us of the reason for their gathering, at which point, it is not so much a surprise as a perfectly natural revelation. Years ago, the eldest Yokoyama son Junpei drowned tragically while trying to save the life of another. Today is the anniversary of his death.


Throughout the course of the day old feelings are remembered, and tensions never forgotten re-emerge. We understand the silent pain behind Kyohei’s gruff, bitter nature, walking out of family photos and telling kids off. And we feel the guilt of Ryota not being able to live up to the promise and standards of his lost brother. Perhaps the most emotionally complex scene comes when Toshiko invites a young man over to visit, not just any man though, the man whom Junpei saved from drowning. His awkward visit is quite painful to watch, but the real punch comes upon his exit, when the family proceeds to make fun of the pitiful, overweight man in order to suppress their overwhelming grief and hurt that this is who their son sacrificed himself for. Toshiko, who is something of a beacon of cheerfulness throughout the entire film, reveals the depths of her hurt as she responds to her son Ryota’s protests that she invites him each year and will continue to do so just to put him through at least some of the pain they went through. This scene is both shocking and overwhelmingly sad; as you can completely understand the conflicting feelings of a woman whose actions paint her as evil and undeniably human at the same time.

Koreeda continues his brilliant working relationship with cinematographer Yutaka Yamasaki, who was responsible for the many shots of quiet detail I so loved in Nobody Knows. Well I’m happy to say they’re back again in Still Walking, along with use of static camera shots that capture the house and its inhabitants in such a beautifully classical way its almost as though they are on a theatre stage. Below are a few of these quiet, painterly moments that convey so much through image alone.




Last but certainly not least, the acting. Actually, I don’t know if you can even call it acting. It verges on documentary realism. It might be better just to call it real. Real life, or truth, or something. Not a single line of dialogue is out of place. All these characters seem completely and utterly real. Toshiko and Kyohei contradict each others’ stories and bicker like the old grandparents they are; the grandchildren are either hyperactive or introverted, and the adults express their exasperation to their aging parents who keep telling the same stories or have developed strange habits, “When are you going to need this many paper bags??” Once again, Koreeda has created a film that is at its most moving in its quietest moments. He managed to do it amazingly well within the confines of a single apartment in Nobody Knows, but it’s nice to get out into the fresh air and take in the beautiful landscape in Still Walking. This film is like exhaling. It just feels so real, and like all the truly classic dramas, it transcends its origins and medium. Yes it’s a Japanese film, but in the end that hardly matters, I can almost guarantee you will see something of your own family reflected in this day in the life of the Yokoyama family.


29 May 2012

Tokyo-Ga


Wim Wenders, 1985 

I have just watched german filmmaker Wim Wenders’ documentary Tokyo-Ga and I am angry. I found the film self indulgent, disrespectful and even offensive. From what I understood, it was a documentary celebrating Wenders’ love for famed Japanese director Yasujiro Ozu, in which Wenders travels to Tokyo in search of the city he came to know and love through exposure to Ozu’s films, which he describes as “a sacred treasure of the cinema”. This quickly gives way to a meandering culture shock video diary of a foreigner in a big city.

Wenders manages to open his film reasonably well. He eloquently describes not only his feelings toward Ozu’s films, but succinctly sums up their message, influence and importance, setting up a filmic contention that promises what could be a very interesting documentary based around a filmmaker’s personal journey. However, his inclusion of an overly long clip from Ozu’s Tokyo Story, complete with puzzling French subtitles, seems an odd one. Wenders explains his hope to discover Ozu’s Tokyo, or at least what is left of it, even in images or feelings.

Unfortunately, the vast majority of images Wenders offers fall into the category of a “Look how weird and backwards Tokyo is!” travelogue, with Wenders largely abandoning his Ozu documentary in favour of hanging out ALL DAY at Tokyo’s golf driving ranges, and ALL NIGHT  at pachinko parlours obsessively documenting the people and their activities within them. Wenders must have told his Tokyo location manager to tell whoever walked into the frame not to talk to him or interact with the camera in any way, resulting in Wenders successfully distancing himself from every citizen in Tokyo, and “Othering” them at the same time as they are condescendingly depicted as socially disconnected drones wasting their lives in the shallow modern life in the metropolis of Tokyo. Wenders seems to make it clear that he is much more interested in the technology and machinery of Tokyo than its citizens. One particularly awful scene includes Wenders’ delivering via voice over a tirade against the nature of television and its false depiction of the world in his hotel. It is completely unnecessary and is very off putting, serving only to familiarise us with what will become Wenders' constant and intrusive voice over throughout the film. 


This voice over is perhaps the films biggest downfall, Wenders has no qualms with vocalising every one of his inane thoughts and philosophies, none of which are even remotely interesting, which is made sure of through his forced, deadpan delivery. The only time Wenders has anything interesting to say is when he is talking about Ozu, which, it becomes quickly clear, he didn’t really plan on doing much of at all, which is a shame, as this is the one topic he was able to convince me he knew about, as his respect and admiration for the director was so apparent. I can only imagine how vastly the film would be improved if the narration voice over was removed completely.

When Wenders manages to pull himself away from his Tokyo oddities tour (a trip to where the fake plastic food for display in restaurants is made recieved considerable screen time, with Wenders again somehow able to drain it of most of its possible appeal) he interviews two important Ozu collaborators, actor Chishu Ryu and cameraman Yuharu Atsuta. These interviews are far and away the most interesting scenes of the film. I found myself wishing that the film only went for half an hour and consisted solely of these scenes. Yet Wenders handles them with unbridled clumsiness. The main problem is that instead of the interviewees’ answers being subtitled; we are left to rely on Wenders’ emotionless voice over paraphrasing what they have said. This downright rude treatment of his subjects becomes strikingly apparent in the interview with Ozu’s good friend and longtime cameraman Yuharu Atsuta. After a very interesting segment in which he explains Ozu’s camera techniques, a humble Atsuta reminisces about his career in film, explaining how after his mentor Ozu’s death, he never really worked to the best of his ability ever again. This scene carries a huge emotional weight, with Atsuta, overwhelmed, breaking into tears upon recalling such fond memories. But of course, Wenders’ disgusting voice over succeeds in belittling the most interesting and powerful scene in his silly “Documentary”. (Fortunately these highlights are available for viewing on youtube as stand alone scenes.)


If that wasn’t enough, Wenders’ old pal Werner Herzog turns up to add his two cents in, delivering a rant on some subject or another at the top of Tokyo Tower. This scene is not translated, and Wenders is quick to sum Herzog’s German language monologue up as something about “Pure images”. French filmmaker Chris Marker also makes a three second cameo, with Wenders mentioning his then recent film Sans Soleil, much of which was also filmed in Tokyo and is by far a much more interesting, beautiful, heartfelt and respectful documentary tackling the same city. These superficial inclusions of backslapping among directors should have been left out, as they only serve to highlight Wenders’ self indulgence and lack of filmic direction, and disconnection with his subject..

If anything, Wenders’ documentary sheds light on the illusion of cinema. Wenders went to Japan in search of the Tokyo he came to know through the films of Ozu, not surprisingly, he didn’t find it. I am of the opinion that he just didn’t look hard enough. Indeed, there are instances where redemption does seem possible for the film, including a scene in which Chishu Ryu accompanies Wenders to Ozu’s grave, yet Wenders prefers to dwell in nostalgia, clinging to his unnatainable cinematic illusion and focus on the neon metropolis, the footage of which, serving as a veritable time capsule for the look and colours of the 1980s are often quite amazing, perhaps the films strongest asset, if one can overlook the negative attitude they seem to be conveyed with. 


Wenders comments, “In spite of everything, I was impressed by Tokyo.” This can hardly be believed, as he has portrayed the city as a vapid and faceless, distorting it into something unsettling, particularly for those familiar with Japan and its culture. Wenders further achieves this through a bizarre choice of soundtrack, an incongruous mix of avant garde 80s Jazz, which, when juxtaposed with the films visuals, many of which are quite beautiful, is very jarring. The final twenty minutes or so are the strongest in the film, for the sole reason that it is actually about Ozu. The music is finally appropriate, and archival photographs and testimonies from collaborators give us a glimpse into what this film could have been, but instead Wenders has created a self indulgent diary of a film where his hero is pushed aside to make room for himself.

Upon realising Ozu’s Tokyo is nothing more than a memory, preserved forever on celluloid alone, Wenders creates his own. Thus is Tokyo-Ga. I have been to Tokyo four times to date, and while I also may not have found Ozu’s brink-of-modernism postwar Tokyo, I certainly didn’t encounter anything as bleak or lifeless as Wenders’ Tokyo.